Permaculture Wizard›Blog›Plants
How to plant a bare-root fruit tree this November
Every November I stand in a nursery yard and look at rows of what seem like dead sticks with muddy feet. They aren't dead. A bare-root fruit tree is a sleeping thing, lifted from the field while its sap rests, and if you tuck it into your soil now it will spend the whole winter quietly reaching out roots while the rest of the garden dreams. I still find that a small miracle. Here is how I plant one so the miracle actually happens.
When is the right time to plant a bare-root fruit tree?
Plant while the tree is dormant: from leaf fall until early spring, whenever the ground isn't frozen. The RHS says bare-root trees are only sold in winter and early spring for exactly this reason, and the UK's Countryside Stewardship rules for orchard grants allow bare-root fruit trees to go in between November and March, while they are not in leaf.
In our Central European gardens, autumn is the sweet spot for the hardy fruits. NDR's garden guide recommends autumn planting for apple, pear, plum and cherry because the soil is still warm, the trees can grow roots before winter, and you don't have to water constantly. The same guide suggests waiting until spring for warmth-loving apricot, peach and nectarine. The Swiss nursery association JardinSuisse agrees that apples, pears, cherries and plums cope well with our climate, while late pears, peaches and apricots need a warm, sheltered spot, often trained flat against a wall.
So: apples and pears now, the apricot in March. That alone saves a lot of heartbreak.
How do you keep the roots alive before planting?
Bare roots hate two things: sun and air. JardinSuisse says the roots must be protected from drying out and from the sun until planting, for example by covering them with wet sacks. Thrive suggests keeping a tree you can't plant straight away in a cold, shaded place, or heeling it into a trench if the ground isn't frozen.
Right before planting, give the roots a drink. The RHS suggests soaking bare-root trees for about 30 minutes; NDR goes for at least an hour. I usually do the hour, then go dig the hole while the bucket does its work.
Before the tree goes in, JardinSuisse recommends a planting cut: remove damaged roots back to healthy wood but leave the thin roots under 5 mm alone, and shorten the shoots of apples, pears, quinces and stone fruit by about a third. Fewer buds means less for the young roots to feed in spring.
How big should the planting hole be?
Wider matters more than deeper. The RHS asks for a hole no deeper than the roots but ideally at least three times the root system's diameter, and suggests breaking up compacted sides with a fork. Bavaria's agricultural institute, the LfL, gives a concrete target for orchard trees: about 80 cm across and 45 cm deep, at least 1.5 times the root volume, and bigger on poorer soil. It also says to keep topsoil and subsoil in separate piles and to loosen the bottom of the hole a spade deep.
If your soil stays wet, note what JardinSuisse says: fruit trees react badly to waterlogging, the kind that follows heavy machinery compacting the ground. That's worth knowing before you dig, not after. On a slope or a heavy clay patch, I watch where the puddles sit in November rain and plant somewhere else.
If voles live on your land (and in much of Switzerland, Germany and Austria they do), this is the moment to fit a wire basket. The LfL recommends mesh of at most 13 mm, a basket at least 60 cm wide and 45 cm deep, closing seamlessly around the root zone and meeting the trunk guard above ground. I've lost a young apple to voles in a single winter. A basket is a small effort for a tree that may outlive me.
How deep do you plant it, and where does the stake go?
Find the graft union, the knobbly swelling low on the trunk where the variety was joined to its rootstock. It must stay above the soil. The Countryside Stewardship rules ask for at least 75 mm above ground, JardinSuisse says about 8 to 10 cm, roughly a hand's width. If the graft is buried, the variety can root on its own and you lose the rootstock's effect on size and vigour.
Put the stake in first, so you don't spear the roots later. Both NDR and JardinSuisse say to drive it into the open hole and set the tree on the side sheltered from the prevailing wind, which in most of our region means the stake sits to the west. The RHS staking guide suggests burying at least 40 cm of stake and tying the tree about 40 to 50 cm above ground with a figure-of-eight tie and a spacer so the bark doesn't rub. Coconut rope works too; JardinSuisse just warns you to check it regularly so it never grows into the bark.
Then fill. Crumble the topsoil back between the roots, give the tree a gentle shake so soil settles into the gaps, and firm it without stamping it into concrete. JardinSuisse adds no fertiliser into the hole. Afterwards it suggests spreading 1 to 2 litres per square metre of well-rotted manure or 2 to 3 litres per square metre of mature compost on the surface.
What happens after planting?
Water it in properly, even in wet November. The LfL recommends at least 20 litres right after planting to close the air pockets, and a watering ring around the tree about 1 m across that holds at least 40 litres. In the first year, it says, water regularly depending on rain, up to twice a month, and in years two and three as needed.
Keep the circle around the trunk free of grass. The LfL says a clear tree circle for at least the first five years gives clearly stronger shoot growth, and NDR suggests a disc about one metre wide, loosened and mulched. Grass is a fierce competitor for water and nitrogen right where the young roots are.
Finally, protect the trunk. The LfL lists trunk guards at least 1.30 m tall against deer and mower damage, kept for at least five years, and suggests a white coating on unprotected bark against sunburn and frost cracks. JardinSuisse mentions shading stems over winter, for example with reed mats.
That circle of mulch is also where the permaculture fun begins next spring: comfrey, chives, daffodils and clover tucked around the drip line. But that's a story for another season. For now, the tree just needs to sleep in good soil.
FAQ
Can I plant a bare-root fruit tree in frozen ground?
No. Every source above says to plant only when the ground isn't frozen. If a hard frost arrives with the tree on your doorstep, keep the roots moist and cool in a shaded spot, or heel it in temporarily, and plant on the next mild day.
Should I put fertiliser in the planting hole?
JardinSuisse advises against adding fertiliser to the hole and recommends spreading mature compost or well-rotted manure on the surface instead. NDR suggests mixing some compost and a little horn shavings into the backfill and says further fertiliser isn't needed.
How long does the stake need to stay?
NDR says the support can usually come off after about two years. The Countryside Stewardship rules say to keep stakes and ties in place until the tree is established and then remove them. Check the tie each spring so it never cuts into the bark.
Which fruit trees should wait until spring?
NDR recommends spring planting for warmth-loving apricot, peach and nectarine. Apples, pears, plums and cherries are happy going in this autumn.
Before you pick the spot, drop a pin and check your land's frost dates, slope and winter sun at https://permawiz.com/site-check/.
autumnbare-rootfruit treesorchardplanting